Write About Tuesday Afternoon, Not Leadership

Of all the Common App essay categories that cross an editor's desk, leadership may be the one that arrives most finished—and least alive.

The student ran the club, captained the team, organized the fundraiser, and the essay reports it the way a résumé would: here is what I did; here is what it proves about me. None of it is untrue. It has simply already been said, in almost exactly this shape, by everyone else applying to the same school.

The instinct isn't wrong. The leadership happened, and it mattered. What disappears is the difference between reporting an achievement and remembering an afternoon.

I learned to lead is a conclusion. It's the kind of sentence a student reaches for because it sounds like what an essay is supposed to say—not because it describes anything that happened during a particular hour on a particular day.

Here's the alternative, and it isn't write about something other than leadership.

It's this: stop narrating the position and go find the Tuesday.

Not the banquet where the position was recognized. Not the election, the award, or the final game. Find the ordinary practice, meeting, rehearsal, or ride home where something small and specific actually occurred.

The thing someone said that didn't want to be said.

The moment the plan quietly fell apart.

The person who wouldn't cooperate.

The decision you made before you knew whether it was the right one.

The strange fact that leading turned out to feel nothing like the word leadership had promised.

That isn't a smaller story than I was captain. It's the same story, minus the summary standing in front of it.

Leadership is a label a college puts on a folder. It was never the essay. The essay is what happened on Tuesday afternoon.

And this isn't unique to leadership. Leadership is simply the clearest example because the category arrives almost pre-written. Any subject can show up as a conclusion instead of a memory:

I overcame adversity.

I found my passion.

This taught me resilience.

Those sentences may all be true. But truth summarized is not yet a story.

The fix is the same each time: move backward.

Somewhere behind the sentence a student already knows how to write is an afternoon they haven't thought to mention. A room. A conversation. A mistake. Something noticed too late. Something understood differently afterward.

Go find the Tuesday. That's usually where the essay is waiting.

This is the same principle the exercises in Act I of Rising are designed to surface: moving past the conclusion you already know toward the story underneath it.

See how it works →

More on choosing a topic: Common App essay FAQ →

From the Editor’s Desk → Continue the conversation with A.M. Arden on Substack.

Don't write about leadership. Write about Tuesday afternoon.